Since 1997 | Your Pittsburgh Law Firm
Your Pittsburgh Law Firm
Flaherty | Fardo | Rogel | Amick

Medical Malpractice

Pittsburgh Medical Malpractice Attorneys

Pittsburgh Medical Malpractice Attorneys

With over sixty (60) years combined experience, the medical malpractice lawyers of Flaherty Fardo have recovered millions of dollars for victims of medical neglect and malpractice. Our experiences includes verdicts, awards and settlements on behalf of men, women and children of all ages and all backgrounds.

Medical malpractice is defined as the deviation from the acceptable standard of care by a doctor, hospital and/or healthcare professional. It is often called negligence or medical neglect. To win a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania, the Plaintiff has to basically prove three (3) things:

  1. A physician or other healthcare provider was in fact "negligent" (which means deviated from the acceptable standard of care);
  2. That the negligence was a proximate "cause" of any harm suffered; and
  3. That the Plaintiff actually suffered "harm".

These three (3) elements of "negligence", "cause" and "harm" must all be satisfied to have a successful medical malpractice claim. Most malpractice lawyers reviewing potential cases, actually start with understanding the "harm" first, because unless the "harm" is severe enough, it may not make sense to accept the case from a time or cost perspective. Malpractice cases can be costly and time consuming. However, if all three (3) elements are met, then there is typically adequate insurance coverage to compensate injured victims of medical malpractice claims.

PA Statute of Limitations for Medical Malpractice Cases

The statute of limitations for Pennsylvania medical malpractice cases is typically two (2) years from the date of the alleged negligence, but can be tolled or extended in limited circumstances involving either minors (under age 18), and/or if it was not possible for the Plaintiff to have learned of the negligence because of other factors.

Pennsylvania Certificate of Merit

Pennsylvania also requires a Certificate of Merit in order to proceed with a medical malpractice case. The Certificate of Merit is the acknowledgement by another physician in the same or similar field, that they reviewed the case, and that in their medical opinion, the defendant was 1) negligent, and that the negligence 2) caused 3) harm. These experts opinions must be documented in writing and stated with a reasonable degree of medical certainty. Notice of the Certificate of Merit should be filed at the same time of the filing of the complaint.

Types of Malpractice Cases We Handle

Our Practice has handled a variety of medical malpractice cases, including but not limited to:

  • surgical errors,
  • OB/GYN mistakes,
  • anesthesia errors,
  • emergency room mistakes,
  • failure to diagnose or misdiagnosis,
  • lack of informed consent, and
  • plastic surgery errors.

We carefully screen each medical malpractice case before accepting it and believe each medical malpractice case is unique and needs to be treated that way. At our firm, we typically use a minimum of three (3) lawyers assigned to each malpractice case, and limit the number of cases that we actually accept.

Free Medical Malpractice Case Review

Choosing the right medical malpractice lawyer is crucial in obtaining the best result for your case. The decision to sue a doctor or hospital in Pennsylvania is not an easy decision. Pennsylvania juries (with the exception of possibly Philadelphia) can be very conservative. Hundreds of thousands of people are employed by healthcare organizations in our state, and almost everyone knows someone who works in the healthcare field. Often, there can be a jury bias in favor of doctors and hospitals. Therefore, understanding how to screen and prosecute malpractice cases is crucial in winning these cases.

Our intake process typically starts with a call with a malpractice lawyer to understand the basic negligence claims and harm suffered. If we believe the initial facts and injuries support further review, we will have the medical records reviewed by an appropriate physician.

If you believe you or a loved one has suffered harm from a potential malpractice claim, please feel free to email Managing Attorney Noah Fardo at npf@pghfirm.com, or you may call his cell phone directly at 412.855.5511 for a no obligation free consultation.

Medical Malpractice

FAQ

What Is Considered Medical Malpractice in Pennsylvania?

Medical malpractice in Pennsylvania occurs when a doctor, nurse, hospital, or other healthcare provider fails to meet the accepted standard of care, and that failure causes injury, harm, or death to a patient.

✅ What Is the “Standard of Care”?

The standard of care refers to the level of skill, expertise, and attention that a reasonably competent healthcare provider in the same field would provide under similar circumstances. It’s a legal benchmark that accounts for a provider’s training, experience, and the conditions at the time of care.

Medical malpractice is not simply a bad outcome or an honest mistake. To be legally actionable, the care must have fallen below this accepted standard, and directly caused injury that resulted in damages such as pain, disability, additional treatment, or loss of income.

⚖️ What Must Be Proven in a Pennsylvania Medical Malpractice Case?

To bring a valid medical malpractice claim in Pennsylvania, a patient (the plaintiff) must prove:

  1. There was a provider-patient relationship.
  2. The provider deviated from the accepted standard of care.
  3. That deviation directly caused the injury or worsened condition.
  4. The injury resulted in actual damages, such as medical costs, lost wages, or pain and suffering.

Importantly, Pennsylvania law requires a Certificate of Merit — a signed statement from a licensed physician in the same or similar specialty affirming in writing that the care was likely negligent and caused harm.

🏥 Common Examples of Medical Malpractice

Our law firm has handled a wide range of malpractice cases involving:

  • Surgical errors (e.g., wrong site surgery, retained surgical objects)
  • Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis (e.g., missed cancer, stroke, or infection)
  • Emergency room mistakes
  • Birth injuries and OB/GYN negligence
  • Medication or anesthesia errors
  • Lack of informed consent
  • Hospital system failures (e.g., failure to follow up on abnormal test results)

Malpractice can be committed by a wide range of professionals: surgeons, specialists, radiologists, anesthesiologists, nurses, hospital administrators, and more.

💡 Is There a Statute of Limitations?

Yes. In most cases, medical malpractice claims must be filed within 2 years from the date of the harm or the date the patient knew or should have known of the harm. For minors, the clock doesn’t begin until they turn 18. (See: Statute of Limitations for PA Malpractice Cases)

💵 What Damages Can Be Recovered?

Victims of medical malpractice in Pennsylvania may be entitled to compensation for:

  • Past and future medical expenses
  • Pain and suffering
  • Lost wages or earning capacity
  • Scarring, disfigurement, or disability
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Embarrassment or humiliation
  • In wrongful death cases, survivor and estate damages

There are no caps on damages in Pennsylvania for medical malpractice (except for punitive damages, which are limited to 200% of compensatory damages in most cases).

📞 Contact Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick

Medical malpractice cases are complex and time-sensitive. At Flaherty Fardo, we have over 25 years of experience handling malpractice claims across Pennsylvania — from misdiagnosed cancers to surgical and hospital system errors.

We offer free consultations and contingency fee representation — meaning we don’t get paid unless we win your case.

To speak directly with Attorney Noah Fardo or another experienced member of our team, contact us today:

We are passionate about holding healthcare providers accountable — and helping patients and families recover the compensation they deserve.

What Is the Statute of Limitations for Medical Malpractice Cases in Pennsylvania?

In Pennsylvania, the statute of limitations for medical malpractice lawsuits is generally two (2) years from the date the alleged medical negligence occurred or from the date the patient knew or reasonably should have known of the negligence and resulting harm.

This time limit is governed by 42 Pa. C.S. § 5524, which applies to personal injury and professional negligence claims — including those against doctors, hospitals, nurses, and other healthcare providers.

🕒 General Rule: 2-Year Time Limit

If you were injured by a medical mistake, the clock usually starts ticking on the date the negligence occurred and caused harm. You must file your lawsuit within two years or your claim will likely be barred forever.

Example:
If a doctor leaves a surgical instrument inside a patient during surgery on January 1, 2023, and the patient immediately suffers complications, the statute of limitations would expire on January 1, 2025.

Discovery Rule: When the Mistake Isn’t Known Right Away

Pennsylvania law recognizes a “discovery rule”, which allows the statute of limitations to be tolled (paused) in certain situations — specifically when the patient did not and could not have reasonably discovered the injury or malpractice until a later date.

Example:
A patient has a CT scan in March 2021 that shows signs of cancer, but the radiologist fails to report the finding. The cancer is not diagnosed until June 2023. In this case, the two-year statute may begin in June 2023, not March 2021 — if the delay was not reasonably discoverable sooner.

This is highly fact-specific and often contested by healthcare defendants. That’s why early legal evaluation is so important.

👶 Special Rule for Minors

In Pennsylvania, if the medical malpractice involves a minor under age 18, the statute of limitations does not begin to run until the minor turns 18 — regardless of when the injury occurred.

That means the deadline to file a malpractice claim for a minor is typically their 20th birthday.

Example:
A child suffers a birth injury in 2020. The statute of limitations to file a lawsuit would generally expire on the child’s 20th birthday in 2040.

⚠️ Wrongful Death & Survival Actions

  • For wrongful death and survival actions based on medical negligence, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of death, not the date of treatment.
  • These are separate from the personal injury statute and have unique procedural requirements.

📌 Important Takeaways

  • Don’t assume the deadline is obvious. Many malpractice cases involve delayed diagnoses, latent injuries, or minors — all of which can alter the timeline.
  • If you miss the deadline, your case will likely be dismissed — even if your injuries are severe or obvious.
  • Consulting a lawyer immediately after discovering possible malpractice is the best way to protect your rights.

📞 Have Questions? Get a Free Consultation.

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we’ve helped victims of medical negligence throughout Pennsylvania understand their legal rights and preserve their claims. If you're concerned about whether your case is still within the statute of limitations, don’t wait.

There is no fee for a consultation, and no obligation unless we take your case. Let us help you understand your options — before it’s too late.

How Do I Know If I Have a Medical Malpractice Case in Pennsylvania?

If you suspect a doctor, hospital, or healthcare provider made a serious mistake, you may be wondering: Do I have a medical malpractice case? The truth is, not every bad medical outcome means there is a lawsuit — but when negligence causes real harm, you may have a strong legal claim.

The only way to truly know if you have a valid case is to have your medical records reviewed by both experienced medical malpractice attorneys and a qualified physician in the same field as the provider involved.

✅ Three Elements You Must Prove to Win a Medical Malpractice Case in Pennsylvania

Under Pennsylvania law, an injured patient must prove all three of the following elements to succeed in a medical malpractice lawsuit:

  1. Negligence / Deviation from the Standard of Care
    • This means the doctor or medical provider failed to do what a reasonable provider in the same field would have done under similar circumstances.
    • A poor outcome alone is not enough — you must show a clear medical error or failure in judgment or procedure.
  2. Causation
    • You must prove that the mistake directly caused or significantly contributed to the harm you suffered.
    • For example, a delayed diagnosis must have allowed the condition to worsen, or a surgical error must have created new complications.
  3. Damages / Harm
    • Finally, you must show that you suffered real, measurable harm. This may include:
      • Additional medical bills
      • Lost wages
      • Permanent injuries
      • Disability
      • Emotional distress or loss of enjoyment of life

Without all three elements — negligence, causation, and damages — a medical malpractice claim cannot move forward in Pennsylvania.

🩺 Do All Mistakes Lead to Lawsuits?

No. Not every error or unexpected result is considered malpractice. Medicine is not a perfect science. Complications can occur even when doctors do everything right.

That’s why it's so important to have your case reviewed by a qualified attorney — and if necessary, an independent physician who can offer an expert opinion.

At Flaherty Fardo, we do not pursue cases unless a doctor is willing to confirm in writing that there was a deviation from the accepted standard of care that caused harm. This written opinion is required under Pennsylvania law as part of the Certificate of Merit process.

🧠 Common-Sense Signs That Malpractice May Have Occurred

Even without medical training, patients and families often have a sense that something went wrong. Red flags may include:

  • A procedure that didn’t go as planned — without any clear explanation
  • A delay in diagnosis or treatment that led to worsening health
  • A medical team that avoids questions or is inconsistent in their explanations
  • A second opinion that drastically differs from the initial care
  • A sudden or unexpected death following a routine medical procedure

If any of these apply, trust your instincts and seek legal advice. The earlier you act, the better.

📋 We’ll Help You Determine If You Have a Case — For Free

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we take pride in providing free case evaluations for individuals and families who suspect medical malpractice. Here’s how it works:

  • You’ll speak directly with an attorney, not just a staff member.
  • If we think your case has merit, we’ll offer to obtain and review the medical records.
  • When appropriate, we consult independent, board-certified physicians to determine whether the standard of care was violated and whether the negligence caused the injury.
  • We advance 100% of all costs if we accept the case — and you owe nothing unless we recover compensation for you.

📞 Contact Us Today for a Free Consultation

If you’re unsure whether you have a medical malpractice case, we’ll help you figure it out.
There’s no risk, no pressure, and no upfront cost.

📱 Call Managing Attorney Noah Paul Fardo directly at 412.855.5511
📧 Email us at info@pghfirm.com
🌐 Visit us online at www.pghfirm.com

You deserve answers — and we’re here to help you get them.

What Should I Do After a Medical Mistake Has Happened?

If you suspect that you or a loved one has been the victim of a medical mistake or error, the actions you take immediately afterward can make a major difference — both for your health and for your legal rights. Medical malpractice cases are complex, and early action can help preserve critical evidence and improve your chances of a successful claim.

Whether the harm occurred in a hospital, during surgery, or under the care of a specific doctor or provider, here are the essential steps you should take after a suspected medical error in Pennsylvania:

✅ 1. Ask Direct Questions Immediately

Do not wait. One of the most effective ways to gather information is by asking direct questions to the doctors, nurses, or hospital administrators involved.

  • Ask, “What happened?
  • Was this a known risk or preventable complication?
  • Is there anything I should know that wasn’t discussed before treatment?
  • Who made the decision to…?” (order a procedure, delay treatment, discharge, etc.)

Doctors are often more honest in the hours or days immediately following a bad outcome — before legal or insurance departments intervene. You may receive critical admissions or explanations that won’t be repeated later.

We recommend:

  • Taking written notes during or immediately after any conversation.
  • Bringing a witness (friend, family member) to serve as a second set of ears.
  • Writing down names, times, job titles, and anything said that seemed unusual or alarming.

These early interactions can become crucial later if litigation becomes necessary.

📁 2. Request a Copy of the Medical Records Immediately

Do not delay. If you suspect a medical error, request a full set of medical records as soon as possible — ideally before you leave the hospital or medical office.

Medical records can be:

  • Edited, supplemented, or “updated” after the fact
  • Incomplete or missing critical data
  • Subject to delays in production, especially once a lawsuit is filed

Ask for:

  • Complete medical chart
  • Nursing notes
  • Medication logs
  • Surgical reports
  • Radiology images (on CD if possible)
  • Discharge summary
  • Consent forms
  • Audit trail if available (shows who accessed or altered the records)

Requesting records early ensures that you obtain them in their original form and avoids excuses or roadblocks down the line.

👨‍⚖️ 3. Contact a Medical Malpractice Attorney as Soon as Possible

The days and weeks after a medical error are the most critical time to begin an investigation. A skilled medical malpractice lawyer can:

  • Preserve evidence
  • Begin gathering medical opinions from experts
  • Help you understand whether a valid legal claim exists
  • Protect you from communicating with risk management or insurance reps without counsel

Most medical malpractice cases require an expert doctor to confirm that the care fell below accepted standards and caused harm. Lawyers with experience in this area — like our firm — have access to board-certified physicians to review your case early and confidentially.

Time is a factor. In Pennsylvania, medical malpractice claims are governed by strict statutes of limitations, typically requiring lawsuits to be filed within 2 years of the date of injury (or when the injury was discovered or reasonably should have been discovered). For minors, the deadline is extended, but early action is still crucial.

⚠️ Bonus Tips

  • Do not sign any releases or settlements from the hospital or doctor until you speak with a lawyer.
  • Preserve any evidence (photos, medication bottles, surgical implants, or written instructions).
  • Avoid discussing the event on social media. Anything you say publicly may be used against you later.
  • Keep a journal of your symptoms, recovery, and how the injury has impacted your daily life.

🩺 We Can Help

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we take medical malpractice seriously. If you suspect a medical mistake, we will listen to your story, provide an honest evaluation, and — if appropriate — begin a detailed investigation with expert physician input.

We offer free consultations and will advance 100% of the costs if we accept your case. There is no fee unless we win.

📞 Call Managing Attorney Noah Paul Fardo directly at 412.855.5511
📧 Email us at info@pghfirm.com
🖥️ Learn more at www.pghfirm.com

Your health and your future matter. Let us help you take the right steps forward.

How Do I Get a Copy of My Medical Records in Pennsylvania?

Obtaining a copy of your own medical records should be simple — but in reality, many hospitals and doctors' offices make the process frustrating and slow. Patients are often met with delays, red tape, or excuses about why records cannot be provided quickly. However, you have a legal right to access your medical records under both federal and Pennsylvania law.

🔑 Your Right to Access Medical Records

Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and Pennsylvania’s Medical Records Act, patients have the right to obtain copies of their own records, including:

  • Office visit notes
  • Operative reports
  • Discharge summaries
  • Imaging studies (X-rays, CTs, MRIs)
  • Lab results
  • Prescriptions
  • Billing records

You can also authorize someone else — like a family member or attorney — to obtain them on your behalf by signing a proper HIPAA-compliant authorization.

✅ Steps to Obtain Your Medical Records in Pennsylvania

  1. Identify the correct medical records department.
    • For hospitals, contact the Health Information Management (HIM) or Medical Records Department.
    • For private practices, speak directly to the office manager or the billing staff — not just the receptionist.
  2. Request the provider’s medical records release form.
    • Most hospitals and healthcare systems (UPMC, AHN, etc.) have their own medical record request formsavailable online.
    • You can also send a general HIPAA-compliant request letter if they don’t have a specific form.
  3. Include the following in your written request:
    • Your full name and date of birth
    • The exact records you’re requesting (include specific dates of treatment)
    • How you’d like to receive them (electronic, CD, paper copy)
    • A signed HIPAA authorization (if you are having a lawyer or representative request them)
  4. Submit the request directly to the provider.
    • Send your request by fax, email, or certified mail so you have a record of when it was sent.
    • Some providers use third-party vendors like Ciox or MRO to handle records. Ask who is managing their requests.
  5. Follow up.
    • HIPAA requires that records be provided within 30 days, though many providers try to delay.
    • If they haven’t complied, you can file a complaint with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) or the Pennsylvania Department of Health.

📝 Special Notes for Malpractice Cases

If you’re considering a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania, getting complete and timely access to your records is critical. Our firm typically handles all medical record requests for our clients, and we ensure the requests are properly drafted, track delivery, and confirm that all relevant materials are provided, including:

  • Radiology CDs
  • Nursing notes
  • Medication administration records
  • Audit trails (in certain cases)

We also make sure the full electronic medical record (EMR) is requested, including internal messages, provider access logs, and other hidden data that often helps prove malpractice.

⚠️ Can They Charge Me?

Yes, but only within limits. Pennsylvania law allows providers to charge a reasonable fee for copying medical records:

  • A flat retrieval fee may apply.
  • Per-page charges (e.g., $1.64 for the first 20 pages, $1.22 for pages 21–60, and $0.41 thereafter) can apply for paper copies.
  • Electronic records must be provided at a lower cost (usually capped at $6.50 under HIPAA if provided electronically).

Fees must be disclosed in advance. If the fees are unreasonable or not clearly itemized, you can dispute them.

🩺 Need Help?

If you're having trouble getting your medical records — or you're unsure where to begin — our firm can help. We routinely assist clients in securing complete medical records for malpractice reviews and legal actions.

📞 Call Managing Attorney Noah Paul Fardo directly at 412.855.5511
📧 Or email our office info@pghfirm.com
🖥️ Learn more at www.pghfirm.com

We’re here to help you get the information you’re entitled to — and to fight for justice if your care was negligent.

Should I Go Back to the Same Doctor After a Medical Mistake?

It depends — but proceed with caution.

At Flaherty Fardo, we never give medical advice, and your health should always come first. If you believe a particular doctor offers the best care for your condition, you should do what is best for your medical well-being — regardless of any legal concerns.

That said, from a legal perspective, we generally do not recommend continuing treatment with a doctor or provider you believe may have committed malpractice — unless it is absolutely necessary for your health or continuity of care.

There are two important reasons for this:

  1. Trust and safety: If you believe a doctor made a serious medical error, it’s reasonable to question whether that same doctor should continue treating you or your loved one.
  2. Credibility in court: Juries may view it skeptically if a patient continues to treat with the same doctor they are suing for negligence. It can create confusion or suggest that the alleged malpractice wasn’t as serious as claimed.

This advice can vary in cases involving hospital systems or teams of providers, where ongoing treatment may be unavoidable or less clearly tied to the individual accused of wrongdoing.

Choosing your doctor is a deeply personal and medical decision — and your health must always come before any legal strategy. But if you're pursuing a malpractice claim, it's important to understand how continued treatment with the same provider may impact your case.

📞 If you’d like a free consultation to discuss your legal options, call Noah Paul Fardo at 412.855.5511 or reach our office at 412.802.6666
📧 Or email us anytime at info@pghfirm.com

We're here to help you make smart, informed decisions.

How Do I Find the Best Pittsburgh Medical Malpractice Lawyer for My Case?

Finding the best medical malpractice lawyer in Pittsburgh means finding someone with the right experience, trusted reputation, and a personal approach you feel confident in. Medical malpractice cases are complex, time-intensive, and often require significant resources to pursue. Not every attorney is equipped to handle them effectively.

To help ensure you choose the right lawyer for your case, here are a few essential tips:

✅ Research Their Experience

Make sure the attorney regularly handles medical malpractice cases, not just personal injury claims in general. Ask how many malpractice cases they’ve handled, what kinds of results they’ve achieved, and whether they’ve taken cases to trial.

✅ Ask About Medical Resources

Good malpractice lawyers have access to qualified medical experts and know how to interpret complex medical records. Without that, your case likely won’t go far.

✅ Look for Real Involvement

Avoid firms that assign cases to associates or case managers. You want an attorney who is personally invested in your case and available to communicate directly.

✅ Read Reviews and Client Testimonials

Look for attorneys with consistent, positive client feedback — not just flashy ads or awards.

✅ Schedule Consultations

Speak with more than one law firm. Ask them tough questions. See who listens, who is honest, and who you trust most with something this serious.

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we have more than 25 years of experience helping malpractice victims throughout Pennsylvania. We’ve handled cases involving misdiagnosis, surgical errors, hospital negligence, and wrongful death, and we take pride in offering our clients direct access to their attorney every step of the way.

📞 For a free consultation, call Managing Attorney Noah Paul Fardo at 412.855.5511 or reach our office at 412.802.6666
📧 Or email us at info@pghfirm.com

We’d be honored to talk with you — and if we take your case, no one will work harder to help you.

Will You Review My Medical Malpractice Case for Free?

Yes — we offer free consultations, but not every case receives a full physician review.

Our process begins with a conversation — you’ll speak directly with an experienced medical malpractice attorney who will listen, ask questions, and offer honest initial impressions at no cost to you.

If we believe your case has potential merit, we may then offer to obtain and review your medical records. In appropriate cases, we will also have those records reviewed by a physician to determine whether there was a deviation from the standard of care.

However, we do not offer full physician reviews in every case. We must first determine:

  1. Whether medical negligence likely occurred, and
  2. Whether that negligence caused meaningful harm.

If both criteria are met, and we accept your case, we will advance 100% of the costs — including expert reviews, medical records, depositions, and court filings. You only repay us if we win.

📞 To schedule a free consultation, call Managing Attorney Noah Paul Fardo directly at 412.855.5511 or reach our office at 412.802.6666.
📧 You can also email us at info@pghfirm.com.

We’re here to listen — and if we can help, no one will work harder to win your case.

What Do You Charge for Medical Malpractice Cases?

We handle all medical malpractice and medical negligence cases on a contingency fee basis — meaning:

👉 You pay nothing unless we win.

Our law firm advances 100% of the costs necessary to pursue your case, including:

  • Expert medical reviews and testimony
  • Filing fees and court costs
  • Depositions and litigation expenses

We are only reimbursed for those costs out of your share of the recovery, and only if we are successful. There is absolutely no financial risk to you or your family.

At Flaherty Fardo, we routinely invest substantial resources into prosecuting complex malpractice cases. If we accept your case, it’s because we believe in it — and in you.

If you or a loved one has suffered due to medical negligence, we offer free consultations and will make any accommodations necessary, whether that means meeting at your home, hospital, or over the phone.

📞 Call us at 412.802.6666
📧 Email us at info@pghfirm.com
We're here to listen — and to help.

What Is The Standard Fee Agreement For Medical Malpractice Cases?

The most standard attorney fee for medical malpractice cases in Pennsylvania is 40% of the total recovery, whether through settlement or verdict.

Importantly, clients never pay out-of-pocket unless there is a recovery. Any costs advanced by our firm (such as expert witness fees, filing fees, and medical records) are reimbursed from the client’s portion of the recovery only if we win.

We attempt to keep our clients fully informed of case-related expenses throughout the litigation so they always understand what is being spent — and what will ultimately be deducted from their portion of the recovery.

If you have questions about contingency fees or want to discuss your specific situation, we offer free consultations.
📞 Call us at 412.802.6666 or 📧 email info@pghfirm.com to speak directly with a malpractice attorney.

Should You Try to Settle Your Medical Malpractice Case Before Filing Suit?

It depends. In some situations, early resolution can be a smart strategy — especially if liability is clear and the hospital or physician expresses a willingness to negotiate in good faith. We have successfully resolved a number of cases through early resolution programs with local healthcare providers.

However, most medical malpractice claims are not taken seriously until after a lawsuit is filed. Filing suit shows the defendants that you're prepared to fight — and it allows the case to be properly valued once they see:

  • The detailed legal allegations
  • The extent of your injuries and damages
  • The expert report from your physician stating there was clear negligence

The value of a case often increases after a complaint is filed because the defense can no longer ignore or downplay your claim. At that point, they are forced to evaluate their risk of liability and potential damages at trial.

We always explore early settlement if it makes sense — but we never advise settling prematurely if it means undervaluing your case.

Ultimately, the decision to settle or proceed to trial is always yours. Our role is to make sure you have the information, expert support, and legal advice you need to make the best possible choice for your future.

Questions about your options? Contact us at 412.802.6666 or email info@pghfirm.com for a free consultation.

How Long Does A Medical Malpractice Case Take in Pennsylvania?

It depends — but most medical malpractice cases in Pennsylvania take anywhere from 18 months to 2.5 years to reach resolution. Some cases, particularly those involving complex medical issues, multiple defendants, or appeals, may take 3 to 5 years or longer to fully prosecute through trial and post-trial motions.

Every case is unique. The timeline depends on:

  • The number of healthcare providers or institutions involved
  • The volume and complexity of the medical records
  • The need for expert reviews in multiple specialties
  • The court’s schedule
  • Whether the defense engages in delay tactics or offers early settlement

⚠️ Caution: Some lawyers may sign a case but then fail to move it forward efficiently. We’ve seen cases languish for years because the attorney didn’t prioritize the client’s interests.

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we work hard from day one to push your case forward strategically. Whether we’re pursuing early settlement or preparing for trial, our goal is to resolve your case as efficiently and effectively as possible— without unnecessary delay.

Contact us today at 412.802.6666 or email info@pghfirm.com for a free consultation about your case.

Will I Have to Pay Any Costs in a Pennsylvania Medical Malpractice Case?

Typically, no — our clients do not pay any out-of-pocket costs during the case and are not at risk for personal financial loss if the case is unsuccessful.

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we advance the litigation costs necessary to prosecute the case, including expert fees, medical records, depositions, and court filings. These costs are only reimbursed to the firm if and when there is a successful recovery. In other words, we only get paid if you get paid.

Clients are responsible for reimbursing the firm’s advanced costs from their portion of the recovery, but not before. Throughout the case, we provide transparent updates so our clients are always informed about what costs have been incurred.

We are mindful to keep expenses reasonable and strategic. Our goal is to maximize your net recovery, not to over-litigate or waste resources.

Questions? Call us today at 412.802.6666 or email us at info@pghfirm.com for a free consultation.

How Much Is My Medical Malpractice Case Worth in Pennsylvania?

The value of a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania depends on several key factors — primarily the severity of the harm suffered and the degree of negligence by the healthcare provider.

Injured patients can pursue compensation for a range of damages, including:

  • Past and future medical expenses
  • Lost wages and lost earning capacity
  • Out-of-pocket costs related to the injury

In addition to these economic losses, Pennsylvania law also allows recovery for pain and suffering, which may include:

  • Physical pain and discomfort
  • Emotional distress and mental anguish
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Embarrassment or humiliation
  • Loss of companionship or reduced likelihood of marriage

Every case is different. The nature of the injury, the recklessness of the conduct, the credibility of the parties, and the venue (location of trial) all influence potential case value. Pain and suffering awards are highly subjective and vary with each jury.

The true value of a malpractice case is only determined after a careful analysis of the evidence, the parties involved, the strength of expert medical opinions, and a complete understanding of how the injuries have affected the plaintiff’s life.

At Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick, we take the time to get to know our clients, investigate thoroughly, and evaluate each case with the respect it deserves. If you have questions about the potential value of your case, we offer free consultations and honest assessments.

Contact us today at 412.802.6666 or email info@pghfirm.com to schedule a consultation.

What Is the Pennsylvania ‘Certificate of Merit’?

The Pennsylvania Certificate of Merit is a mandatory statement from a qualified medical professional affirming that there is a reasonable probability that the care, skill, or knowledge exercised or exhibited in the treatment fell outside acceptable professional standards.

Since 2003, Pennsylvania law requires that a plaintiff’s attorney must file a Certificate of Merit in order to proceed with a medical malpractice lawsuit. This certificate must be signed by another physician — in the same or similar specialty — stating that there is a valid basis to believe the defendant was negligent and that the negligence caused harm to the patient.

Importantly, this certificate must be filed within 60 days of filing the complaint. Failure to obtain and file a valid Certificate of Merit can result in the case being dismissed. For anyone considering a medical malpractice lawsuit in Pennsylvania, understanding and securing a Certificate of Merit is a critical early step.

If you have questions about whether your case may qualify as malpractice, contact Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick for a free consultation at (412) 802-6666 or email us directly at info@pghfirm.com.

What Is Your Past Experience With Medical Malpractice Cases?

For more than 25 years, Flaherty Fardo has helped victims of medical malpractice recover substantial compensation for life-changing injuries and losses.

We have successfully handled a wide range of malpractice claims, including:

  • Surgical errors
  • Emergency room negligence
  • Misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis
  • Failure to diagnose
  • Lack of informed consent
  • Hospital and nursing negligence

Our cases have involved a variety of healthcare providers—hospitals, surgeons, OB/GYNs, primary care physicians, specialists, and emergency department staff.

We’ve secured favorable settlements and verdicts in Allegheny County and across Pennsylvania, including Washington, Westmoreland, Elk, Fayette, and Clearfield Counties.

Medical malpractice lawsuits are among the most complex and resource-intensive cases to pursue. They require deep legal knowledge, strong expert support, and the ability to challenge powerful healthcare systems. We believe our consistent success stems from our tireless preparation, our commitment to clients, and our willingness to take on even the toughest cases.

If you believe you may have a malpractice claim, we offer free consultations and honest advice.

Do You Have Access to Doctors to Review My Medical Malpractice Case?

Yes. We work with a trusted network of board-certified physicians across multiple specialties who assist us in evaluating and prosecuting medical malpractice claims.

Access to qualified medical experts is one of the most important components of a successful malpractice case. These experts help us determine whether a healthcare provider violated the standard of care, and whether that negligence caused harm.

Over the years, we’ve built strong relationships with physicians who have provided expert opinions in surgical errors, misdiagnoses, medication mistakes, birth injuries, and other complex malpractice claims. When we review new cases, we often begin by consulting with specialists we’ve worked with before—and whose integrity and credentials we trust.

This depth of medical support is a key advantage we bring to our clients.

Why Should I Choose Flaherty Fardo as My Medical Malpractice Lawyer?

Because if we accept your case, no one will work harder to help you.

Choosing the right medical malpractice attorney can be one of the most important decisions you make. At Flaherty Fardo, we offer experienced, aggressive representation with one focus: putting our clients’ best interests first.

We understand that the financial and emotional consequences of medical malpractice can last a lifetime. That’s why we only accept cases we are fully committed to—and when we do, we fight relentlessly to win.

Here’s what sets us apart:

  • Access to Medical Experts: We maintain an extensive database of trusted physicians and consultants across specialties. In medical malpractice cases, having the right medical experts can make or break your claim.
  • Proven Results: We have recovered millions of dollars for victims of malpractice across Pennsylvania. Our case experience includes surgical errors, hospital negligence, delayed diagnoses, informed consent violations, and more.
  • Hands-On, Personal Attention: We pride ourselves on being accessible. When you work with us, you’ll have direct communication with the lawyers handling your case. You’ll never be left wondering about the status of your claim.

If you or a loved one has suffered harm due to medical negligence, contact us today for a free and confidential consultation. We will tell you honestly if we can help—and if we can, we’ll go all in.

📞 412.802.6666
📧 info@pghfirm.com

Flaherty | Fardo | Rogel | Amick

Case Results

Past success does not guarantee future results, but does demonstrate our experience and knowledge as successful Pennsylvania trial attorneys.

$1.25 Million

Medical Malpractice - Botched Plastic Surgery

Our firm filed a medical malpractice lawsuit on behalf of a patient injured during a negligently performed breast reduction procedure. The case raised important concerns about cosmetic surgeons performing procedures typically reserved for board-certified plastic surgeons. The matter was resolved for $1,250,000 in compensation for our client.

Medical Malpractice
Personal Injury
$1.25 Million

Medical Malpractice - Emergency Room Mistakes

We represented a family in a medical malpractice case involving allegations that a hospital and its emergency room physicians negligently misdiagnosed and prematurely discharged a patient in need of urgent care. Through dedicated advocacy, we secured a recovery of approximately $1.25 million for the family.

Medical Malpractice
$6.3+ Million

Medical Malpractice - Physician Errors

Our firm successfully resolved a complex Pennsylvania medical malpractice case involving multiple physicians and a healthcare practice. The lawsuit alleged negligent medical care resulting in significant harm. Through persistent litigation, the plaintiff ultimately obtained compensation exceeding $6.3 million.

Personal Injury
Medical Malpractice
Flaherty | Fardo | Rogel | Amick

What Our Clients Say

"Working with Noah I’ve appreciated his fair and practical approach to getting things done. He fears nothing and goes about his business professionally and effectively. His colleagues and staff are always caring and timely. I especially appreciated step by step explanations and details keeping me comfortable thru the legal events. Online documents are convenient and I will continue to call on Noah for my advice and legal needs. Thanks for all."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"Working with Noah I’ve appreciated his fair and practical approach to getting things done. He fears nothing and goes about his business professionally and effectively. His colleagues and staff are always caring and timely. I especially appreciated step by step explanations and details keeping me comfortable thru the legal events. Online documents are convenient and I will continue to call on Noah for my advice and legal needs. Thanks for all."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"Attorney Fardo and his staff were responsive, available and walked me through the complex legal process in a simple and compassionate way. Incredible team!"

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"I’ve been with Noah for over 10 years. His firm has represented myself and my three corporations over the last 10 years. He has been the best lawyer I’ve ever been a client of. The personal attention to each case I get from him and his colleagues is remarkable."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"I’ve worked with Noah for over two decades and he has represented me in multiple cases, from civil litigation, tax issues, small business matters, to my divorce. He and his staff are very approachable and provide updates throughout the process. I have always felt very comfortable and at ease knowing that Noah is a simple phone call away for any of my legal needs."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"Noah and his team are the absolute best. They took a very painful time of my life and completely made it so much better. They are very respectful of your situation and always answered questions in a timely manner. I do not know what would have happened if it wasn't for Noah. I cannot express how thankful I am for Noah and his team. There cannot possibly be anyone better!!!"

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"Noah was referred by a long time friend. He responded quickly and made me feel supported. My personal injury case was pursued and settled to my great satisfaction. Everything about our interactions was exceptionally professional. His practice includes a team of dedicated professionals and state of the art facilities. Scheduling of depositions, record retrieval, and video conferencing went conveniently and smoothly. This was the first time I needed a lawyer; I’m glad I met Noah."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Ralph

"My firm provides business consulting services to the healthcare space. I have referred Noah and members of his team to many clients over the years. He provides the type of personal service that my clients demand of me. I appreciate the personal services and look at his team as an extension of mine."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Kevin

"I have had three lawyers prior to hiring Mr. Fardo. He has out done each and every other lawyer I have ever had. Great knowledge and very responsive. I have been with this Lawfirm for 15 years and they have helped me with all of my business and personal legal issues. Thanks Mr. Fardo"

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Eddie

"We were referred to Noah of which became a blessing for us. It's sometimes an uneasy feeling working with someone you don't know. Noah made us feel very comfortable and yet held that professionalism needed to give us the confidence we needed in him. He kept us informed of every aspect of the case and at times we would have never expected we would receive Emails from him. He is extremely considerate of not only the party he is representing but others as well. All of the Ratings above do not fulfill the feelings we have for Noah. If you need an Attorney, this is the Man you WANT."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
W. David

"Mr. Fardo is one of the few attorneys left who properly charges you for his time. He has never overcharged me, he stays focused even though he has many cases going on at one time. His staff is very professional and knowledgeable. I would absolutely recommend Mr.Fardo to anybody."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Joe

"I currently reside in NC, and every time I require an attorney, I find myself comparing them to Noah. PA is lucky to have him. In terms of litigation, you can't find anyone better."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Camille

"NOAH HAS BEEN A GREAT ATTORNEY AND FRIEND FOR THE LAST 10 YEARS. HE ALWAYS LISTENS AND IS EASY TO TALK TO. HE TREATS MY FAMILY AND I LIKE WE ARE APART OF HIS FAMILY. THE STAFF AS WELL IS ALWAYS HELPFUL AND KIND."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Charlie

"Noah has not only represented me in the past, but, as a fellow attorney, I never hesitate to make referrals to Noah. He is very professional, does an excellent job, cares about his clients, and responds promptly to calls and concerns of both current clients and prospective clients."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Jamie

"I have known and worked with Noah Fardo for years. He has always been extremely professional and goes the extra mile for everyone. His work ethic and passion are second to none. His firm has always kept me well informed every step of the way. I couldn't be happier with his work and I highly recommend Noah and his firm."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anthony

"I required Noah's services for a property tax appeal as well as a shareholder labor dispute with a former company. I found Noah to be well accessible, sensitive to my needs and concerns and focused on doing what is best for me - the client. I found Noah to be very aggressive with my case while staying ethical in the process. I would highly recommend Noah Fardo and his firm."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Anonymous

"Attorney Fardo was extremely knowledgeable and helpful in regards to estate planning for my grandmother. He was able to assist my family with many complex issues and saved us a substantial amount of money. I would definitely retain his legal services for other issues that may arise in the future and would highly recommend him to anyone seeking legal counsel."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Lisa

"I've had the pleasure of knowing Noah Fardo for more than ten years. Over time he has represented me on a number of matters. Noah is conspicuously bright and exceptionally knowledgeable. That said, his best asset is his moral compass. Noah is a genuinely good person and can always be relied upon to do the right thing for his client. I enthusiastically recommend and endorse Noah Fardo."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Tony

"Had a small employment case, and Noah handled it with tenacity. He gave me updates about twice a week and what he said would happen in the beginning is exactly what played out. He acted as a true advocate and was worth every penny."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Brian

"I have used Attorney Fardo as an attorney for over 10 years for personal and professional matters. In my professional career I have had dealings with dozens of attorneys. I chose to use Noah Fardo because of his accessibility and common sense attitude. Noah advises me on many issues and is always willing to listen, understand and recommend a course of action. It's a comfort to know that I can pick up the phone and talk to noah in person whenever the need arises unlike many law firms."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Ron

"I cannot say enough good things about Mr. Fardo and his handling of my legal issues. He is in constant contact letting me know of any new developments. His professionalism and tireless preparation have made a difficult time much smoother to deal with. When you truly feel as if your attorney has your best interest at heart, it becomes very easy to step back and allow them to do their job. From very early on in my meetings with Mr. Fardo, he had my complete trust. He is trustworthy, has a great command of the law and is tenacious...in short, everything I had hoped for when I chose my lawyer."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Daniel

"'Highly Recommended' just isn't enough praise. They are by far the best I have ever worked with. Professional, but beyond that their personal touch is exactly what a medical malpractice client or personal injury client needs. Noah Fardo is amazing, but the entire firm were great to us. I honestly can't thank Bill Rogel, Nicole Hauptman Amick, and Jaclyn Gibson enough. Thank you all."

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Eli Schrock

I am an out of State client, over 1500 miles away, and through the 2 years of work on my case I never met anyone from the firm in person, yet they treated me like I lived down the street from the office.

I am very pleased with the professional teamwork, and their patience and timely responses to my requests and to the task at hand. They did all they could do to help with the difficult facts of my case, and I am pleased with the outcome. I would recommend this law firm to anyone with the assurance they would offer the same quality service to them as they did to me. Thank you Flaherty Fardo.

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Carole J. Boyd

"Couldn't have asked for a better experience. They are a wonderful group who are efficient, patient, communicative and do their job very well.They kept me in the loop the whole time and were extremely helpful. I have used a different firm in the past and this was like night and day. If you are considering using Flaherty Fardo for your assessment appeal (or likely anything else they practice) then you found what you are looking for. A special thank you to Nicole who spearheaded my case and answered my never-ending questions. Top notch!"

review starreview starreview starreview starreview star
Glenn Birk
Pittsburgh skyline and bridge
Flaherty | Fardo | Rogel | Amick

Related Media: Videos

Informed Consent In Medical Malpractice Lawsuits

watch now

My Dad's Life

watch now

Welcome to Flaherty Fardo - Your Pittsburgh Law Firm - 2017

watch now

Request a Free Consultation

A man in a dress shirt and tie posing for a picture
Noah Paul Fardo
Managing Partner | Medical Malpractice & Personal Injury Attorney
Thank you for your submission. We try to respond promptly, often within hours. If you need immediate assistance, you can try texting 412.855.5511. Be in touch shortly.

Thank you,
Noah Paul Fardo
Managing Partner
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.